Dolores Canyons Proposals

Do the Dolores Canyons need more protection? And what is the correct level of protection?

The Protect the Dolores Coalition has proposed creation of a new National Monument. The proposed Dolores Canyons National Monument, lies in western Mesa, Montrose and San Miguel counties and is currently shown to contain approximately 390,000 acres.

Opposing the monument proposal is the Halt the Dolores group, which highlights potential impacts on outdoor recreation, agriculture, and mining that could result from the designation of a national monument.

To see current management layers, roads, and the boundaries of both the national monument and NCA proposals, check out the Dolores Canyons mapping tool.

Please note, some of these layers contain a significant amount of data and may take a moment to load. Some layers are also scale dependent and may require you to zoom in before they appear.

Feedback gathered on a draft Dolores Canyon National Conservation Area map

In an effort to balance resource conservation with multiple-use principles and economic vitality, Mesa and Montrose counties developed a draft map for a northern Dolores Canyon National Conservation Area ("NCA") as an alternative to the Dolores Canyon National Monument proposition. The draft Dolores Canyon National Conservation Area is 29,806 acres, including 7,043 acres in the southern portion of the proposed NCA, and 22,763 acres north of the Paradox Valley.

As another starting place for conversation, we gathered input on areas that deserve greater protection, access concerns, etc. The draft map, is available on the Dolores Canyons mapping tool.

Methodology for Draft Boundaries

The boundaries of the map utilize the topography of the Dolores River Corridor.

Guiding Principles

Locally led effort:

Include input from Mesa, Montrose, and San Miguel County residents.
Ensure participation from the Senators' offices and consider using a third-party mediator for negotiations.

Protection of existing rights:

Maintain existing rights, including water rights and grazing leases, while guaranteeing unrestricted access for regular business operations associated with those rights.
Retain access to critical minerals necessary for meeting energy, carbon, and national security goals.

Sustainable resource management:

Balance economic activities with environmental stewardship.
Implement adaptive management practices for grazing and land use.

Infrastructure and public services:

Secure funding for road maintenance and public safety services.
Establish necessary public facilities for visitors.

Cultural and historical preservation:

Protect cultural and historical sites from vandalism and neglect.

Public access and recreation:

Maintain public access for recreation and manage overuse responsibly.
Ensure opportunities for motorized travel, mountain biking, hunting, and fishing.

Wildfire mitigation and environmental protection:

Implement strategies to mitigate wildfire risks and address vegetative invasive species.

Economic and community support:

Establish and maintain coordination and cooperation with local communities and taxing districts to support local economies.
Prevent overburdening of public infrastructure and services.

By focusing on these guiding principles, we hope to find a way to ensure that the needs of local communities are respected while achieving broader environmental, economic, and multiple-use goals.

*Please note: the identified boundaries of the Draft Dolores Canyon National Conservation Area and Proposed Dolores Canyons National Monument are subject to change pending ongoing discussions with stakeholders.

Actions by Mesa County

Management of our public lands

According to the National Park Service:

A “national monument” is a type of park designation. The Antiquities Act at Section 2 defines national monuments as: “confined to the smallest area compatible with proper care and management of the objects to be protected[.]” According to the National Parks Index, “A national monument is intended to preserve at least one nationally significant resource. It is usually smaller than a national park and lacks its diversity of attractions.”

Not all national monuments are established the same way. Some are created by presidents using the authority of the Antiquities Act. Congress also creates national monuments through the legislative process.

The Presidential Proclamation provides details such as "reference to the legal authority/authorities, date of signing/date of establishment, president’s name, a description of scientific values (the rationale for setting aside the national monument), description of boundaries, designation of federal agency manager, and amount of land set aside."¹ It will also dictate that the governing agency will begin developing a new Resource Management Plan (RMP) that will guide future management of the monument. This process is governed by NEPA or the National Environmental Policy Act.

Mesa County is home to the Colorado National Monument established in 1911. National monuments designated today are managed for a variety of purposes, primarily to protect and preserve at least one significant resource. These resources may be natural, cultural, or scientific resources. While the specific management objectives can vary depending on the monument, these lands are managed to balance conservation and the protection of important natural and cultural resources with public access and enjoyment. Management focus generally includes:

Conservation: Protecting and preserving unique or rare ecological features, habitats, and species.
Cultural Preservation: Preserving archaeological sites, historic structures, and culturally significant landscapes.
Recreation: Providing opportunities for outdoor recreation such as hiking, camping, and wildlife viewing while ensuring the protection of natural and cultural resources.
Education: Offering opportunities for public education and interpretation of the monument's natural and cultural resources.
Scientific Research: Supporting scientific research and monitoring to better understand and manage the monument's resources.
Sustainable Use: Managing the monument's resources in a sustainable manner to ensure they can be enjoyed by present and future generations.

National Monuments may also be managed by the Bureau of Land Management or the US Forest Service. These newer monuments tend to be more conservation focused, rather than preservation focused like those managed by the National Park Service. Regarding the 14.9 million acres of National Monuments and National Conservation Area Programs, the BLM states "These areas are managed to conserve, protect, restore, and enhance America’s national and cultural heritage, while providing compatible multiple uses including grazing, oil, gas and mining."²

Footnotes:

¹ How to Research Antiquities Act National Monuments from the National Park Service. Retrieved April 2, 2024.

²National Conservation Lands: Monuments and National Conservation Areas from the U.S. Department of the Interior, Bureau of Land Management. Retrieved April 29, 2024.

Public Lands are managed according to a land management plan, similar to a county's comprehensive plan. These plans serve as a blueprint for the public land and are developed in accordance to a National Environmental Policy Act ("NEPA") process. The area proposed for the Dolores Canyons National Monument traverse portions of the following Resource Management Plans (“RMPs”) and Forest Plans:

These plans identify management areas for recreation, timber extraction, oil and gas and mineral extraction and grazing, as well as areas that require special management such as timing limitations, protections for plant and species habitat, critical watersheds, and more. Some of the protective management designations are listed below. There are also plans that manage specific resources such as Travel Management, species such as the Gunnison Sage-grouse or for uses such as the 2012 Western Solar Plan.

Wilderness Areas are the most protective tool available to federal land managers and is defined as as a place "where the earth and its community of life are untrammeled by man, where man himself is a visitor who does not remain."¹ Established by Congress in 1964, the Wilderness Act... "The uniquely American idea of wilderness protects wild and natural landscapes ranging from alpine to desert, forest to grassland, and other environments of the United States. Wilderness protects the habitat of numerous wildlife species and provides a source of clean water. It has long been used for science and education, providing sites for field trips, study areas for student research, and serving as a source of instructional examples."² Wilderness areas are recommended for designation, Congress then enacts legislation, and upon agreement by the House and Senate, the president will sign the legislation into law.³

Wilderness Areas in Mesa County include:

Wilderness Areas in Montrose County include:

BLM Colorado Wilderness Tabeguache Area

Wilderness Study Areas (WSAs) "are places that have wilderness characteristics; that is a minimum size, naturalness, and outstanding opportunities for recreation which make them eligible for designation as wilderness... The establishment of a WSA served to identify areas for Congress to consider for addition to the National Wilderness Preservation System. Today, the BLM manages WSA that contain about 11.1 million acres of public land. Until Congress makes a decision to add or end consideration of a WSA, the BLM manages the area to ensure its suitability for designation as wilderness is not impaired."²WSAs are typically designated by Congress. Additionally, there have been a few cases in which the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) has identified WSAs during planning processes under Section 202 of the Federal Land Policy and Management Act of 1976.

Lands with Wilderness Characteristics (LWCs), according to the BLM, "For an area to qualify as lands with wilderness characteristics, it must possess sufficient size, naturalness, and outstanding opportunities for either solitude or primitive and unconfined recreation. It may also possess supplemental values. Section 201 of Federal Land Policy and Management Act (FLPMA) requires the BLM to maintain an inventory of all public lands and their resources and other values, which includes wilderness characteristics. It states that the preparation and maintenance of the inventory shall not, of itself, change or prevent change of the management or use of public lands. Lands with wilderness characteristics are inventoried separately from designated Wilderness or wilderness study areas (WSAs)."⁴

Areas of Critical Environmental Concern (ACECs) are “lands where special management attention is required to protect and prevent irreparable damage to important historical, cultural, or scenic values, fish and wildlife resources or other natural systems or processes, or to protect life and safety from natural hazards.”⁵ ACECs are nominated and evaluated during an RMP process and must meet both relevance and importance criteria (43 CFR 1610.7-2).

Colorado Roadless Areas are "important because they are, among other things, sources of drinking water, important fish and wildlife habitat, semi-primitive or primitive recreation areas, including motorized and non-motorized recreation opportunities, and naturally appearing landscapes." the Colorado Roadless Rule was created in response to "Uncertainty about the future of the 2001 Roadless Rule, along with state-specific concerns." The Department of Agriculture, US Forest Service and State of Colorado agreed that "timber cutting, sale, or removal and road construction/reconstruction have the greatest likelihood of altering and fragmenting landscapes, resulting in immediate, long-term loss of roadless area characteristics. Therefore, there is a need to generally prohibit these activities in roadless areas."⁶Colorado has 4,433,000 acres of Inventoried Roadless Areas."⁷

Resource Management Plans (RMPs) encompass a wide array of land management decisions tailored to specific resource management goals. These decisions, shaped by the plan's objectives and the resources under management, aid in balancing conservation and utilization. In addition to designations like WSAs, LWCs, and ACECs, an RMP may also include: identification of special and extensive recreation areas that experience higher usage, delineation of areas suitable and unsuitable for target shooting or dispersed camping, provisions for future rights-of-way permits for solar, wind, and transmission structures, designation of areas requiring timing limitations for specific uses (e.g., oil and gas development, timber extraction) to protect certain species, travel management restrictions in big game winter ranges and during sage grouse lekking and brood rearing periods, and regulations addressing noise disturbances.

Footnotes:

¹U.S. House of Representatives. Title 16, Section 1131.
²National Conservation Lands: Wilderness from the Bureau of Land Management.
³Wilderness Designation from Wilderness.net.
⁴Lands with Wilderness Characteristics from the Bureau of Land Management.
⁵Title 43, Chapter 35 from the U.S. Government Publishing Office.
⁶Federal Register from the U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service.
⁷State Maps from the U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service.

Make your voice heard

While Mesa County is diligently collecting and reviewing all information provided through the mapping tool, we also strongly encourage you to reach out to your State Senators and Representatives, County Commissioners, and City or Town Councilmembers. Your direct engagement with these officials is vital in shaping the outcome of this important decision.

Ways to contact elected officials are provided below.